Salam, I have found overwhelming evidence of the true geographical locations of the prophets and messengers mentioned in the Quran. I ask Dr Hany to read the resources I linked below, reflect upon them and re-examine the Qur'an in a SOUTH ARABIAN locution.
The Summary of all 4 books goes as follows:
- Exodus never happened in Egypt but in South Arabia
- The Promised Land mentioned in the Bible is in South Arabia and not Palestine
- The Title "Pharaoh" never existed in ancient Egypt (as it is used in the Bible) and "Far'awn" mentioned in the Holy Quran is actually a name
- The Septuagint Translation of the Bible caused confusion the about Egypt (as the translation replaced the word "Msrim" with the greek name "Aigypto" due to political reasons.
- All prophets mentioned in the Bible were of south arab origin and the stories of the bible are the legends about them
The PDFs I provided come in 4 volumes of different topics. The first PDF deals with the geographical location of Exodus, the meaning of "Far'awn" in the Qur'an and the Bible, the location of Midyan, who the Children of Israel (Bani Israil) are, the heart of the corruption and so on.
The second PDF deals with the actual meaning of "Hebrew" in the Bible and how it became corrupted to fit certain political agendas, the forgery called "hebrew language", where the actual birthplace of Ibraham was, where the so-called "Promised Land" was located, who the biblical Canaannites are, Sheba and so on.
The third PDF deals with Noah's Ark, how the biblical Ur-Salem (today taken as "Jerusalem") COULD NOT have been in Palestine, the meaning of "Zion", who the biblical Philistines and so on.
The fourth PDF deals with more refutations against the "Egyptian Exodus" and more correlations between the biblical descriptions, names and stories of south arabian locations.
All these PDFs were NOT written by Sam Garrans but a anonymous group of Quran-aloners who dedicated their lifes to spread the truth hidden from us:
not only, it can also be earth, land etc. based on context
Keith El
Jun 26, 2022
Islam, the post is correct. This peer reviewed book (by anthropologist, Dana Reynolds-Marniche) was released in 2021. It confirms Misr is in South Arabia, and is not Egypt. It also confirms all the old Testament Prophets, and events about them, were in South Arabia (Yemen). This makes you rethink the reason for all the war there. I meant to post this way back, and forgot. Thanks!
I think Hany is correct and has produced convincing evidence. Notice where Yemen is located in relation to east Africa. Ethiopia, Somalia and Eritrea is within spitting distance. I don't think a strip of water was going to stop anyone from going back and forth. If memory serve me correct there is a hadith that quotes Mohammed as saying something to the tune of "the whole faith came from Yemen".
I think the whole tradition that we are part of did but I don't think the core concepts originated there. It was an expression of far older stuff that had also touched the countries of India. I think that is why they historically were so positive towards other peoples idols because to them it was just another concept of the most high and near. That went a little out of hand eventually, so it spawned a new tradition where no lasting symbol representing Allah was to be made because a couple of generations in and what was a useful tool to one generation become the confusion of the next. There are just too many similarities at the core for it to be coincidence.
Deleted
Jun 27, 2022
Who is that masked man? Thanks a million Tasky Task. I have downloaded the four pdfs. What a treasure. I have been reading bits and pieces of this information for years but finally received confirmation of a lot of what I have been reading. I cannot thank you enough. Blessings.
I think the whole tradition that we are part of did but I don't think the core concepts originated there. It was an expression of far older stuff that had also touched the countries of India. I think that is why they historically were so positive towards other peoples idols because to them it was just another concept of the most high and near. That went a little out of hand eventually, so it spawned a new tradition where no lasting symbol representing Allah was to be made because a couple of generations in and what was a useful tool to one generation become the confusion of the next. There are just too many similarities at the core for it to be coincidence.
Please contact at kmanzu@yahoo.com to discuss more in details probably via google meet.
Shukran brothers.