In the YT165, last Sunday, Dr Hany told about the way to greet each other using Salamun Alaykum instead of "Assalam o Alaykum" as it is possibly shirk because of Eisa Ibn Marayyam. Also he said same thing in some prior video as well.
So my question is when we say "Assalatu Wassalam alaa Muhammad", and Dr Hany as well, aren't we saying the same "Assalam Alaa" as in the case of Eisa? If so wouldn't it be better to avoid this phrase at all? I am confused. May be I haven't listen/learned properly, or I missed some point. Anyone please explain this for me.
Jazak Allah Khairun Kaseerun.
Sazali Bin Md Rasid
Salaamun Alaikum Brother, what do mean " and Dr Hany as well". Did you hear he say ""Assalatu Wassalam alaa Muhammad". Thanks.
Hafeez ur Rehman
Yes! that is the whole point. Did I misunderstood or totally missed some point? You mean Dr Hany doesn't say this! If so what are the actual words by Dr Hany, I would like to learn that and fix my mistake!!!! IA
Jazak Allah Khairun
Abdullah B.O
Salāamun Aleykum brother,
You missed a lot last year and more. Kindly review YT79 at least: you will find more answers related to this question there
https://youtu.be/yvXfpP5C6Lo?si=tRwh0aaLse3T70U8
After “avoiding saying Allahumma in duās”
I believe (if I recall correctly in that segment or in YT88 about al Fatiha) Dr Hany said he dropped out saying salatu ibrahimiya, ("Allahumma" solii alaa Muhammadin wa alaa ali etc…).
The point is that Dr Hany (to my knowledge) hasn't put yet to the public how to replace the erroneous Duas in traditional salah (I guess your question is related to that or maybe I am wrong). Dr Hany has either encouraged or discouraged doing traditional Salah. What he said for sure among many thing are the followings:
Wherever you used to say "Allahuma" replace it with "Rabana"
Don't use "As-salamun" but say "Salamun"
And restore your Salah (as Quran states) : the form is not stated clearly to the followers of Quran but the content of what you are supose to engage YES.. Many videos on that chanel deals with that but check out YT151 (about the Jumuah).
In a nutshell, Dr Hany just gave the formula, the method and through daily duas you get to taste how to compose your own duas. So you yourself have to onus to fix the errors once you get the evidence-based knowledge.
So I give you an example.. ever since the first day of these disclosures,, instead of salatu ibrahimiya I recite the dua Dr Hany uses to close every segment (Al-hamdulillahi al-lazhii hadana li hadha wa ma kunna etc...)
and wherever I said "as-salamu aleyka ay-yu annabiyu etc..." I instead say " Salamun alaa rasulillah wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu etc..." He was our Rasul and NOT our Nabyi..
Maybe I am wrong in some applications but remember, this is a journey, we are wayferers (ibaad toward Ar-rahman) and as the evidence keep dripping we keep restoring, fixing going forward and toiling.
I hope this give you a context. Salamun aleykum